Was Muhammad a False Prophet?

Would “false prophets” include Muhammad? It’s an impolitic question to ask in these politically correct times, but, thanks to political correctness these are also highly dangerous times. Since a good deal of the danger emanates from the religion Muhammad founded, it seems reasonable to ask if he was a false prophet. And if he was, does that mean that Islam is a false religion?  And if it is, why are Catholic leaders so keen on declaring their solidarity with Islam?

It’s a case of either/or. Either the New Testament account of Jesus is true or Muhammad’s account is true. Since they contradict each other, they both can’t be true.

  • Ed

    I’d say the more relevant question is “are there any real prophets?” (Aside from Al Gore, of course.)

  • Martin B

    Dante had Mo perfectly sorted out seven centuries ago. Today there are Christians trying to drag him out of the Eighth Circle of Hell and into Heaven, and I can’t understand why.

    • Justin St.Denis

      Pope Evita is a communist, like most Jesuits have been since there have been Jesuits. And Jesuits are way more into communism than they are into Jesus Christ. Look at what they have done throughout history in South America.

      Jesuits are not genuine Christians, and Pope Evita is a Jesuit. That’s why. I wish the answer wasn’t so unpleasant, I really do.

  • Shebel

    Believe in ME or I will kill you.
    Don’t believe in me –or I will kill you.
    Islam is a Mystery.

    • Xavier

      Misery. Islam is a Misery.

      • Shebel

        Misery is Islam.

        • Justin St.Denis

          And islam is misery.

  • Justin St.Denis

    Mohammad was many things – a rapist, a pedophile, a warlord, psychotic, homosexual, a murderer, to name a few. Of these, most PRECLUDE or totally disqualify one for prophet status.

    Mohammad was no prophet, the Koran is a cribbed and plagiarized nightmare of convoluted and evil thoughts, and islam is not only a false religion, it is not a religion at all. Ergo, muslims should be happy that alternative terms such as camel-jockeys and sand-monkeys exist to define them instead of just “muslim” and “islam”. Those last two – muslim and islam – are simply confirmations that the person being discussed is a sub-human idiot and likely dangerous.

    The only “muslims” I know that are exempted from the above are people who have not set foot inside a mosque in over a decade.

  • mikeh420

    He was no prophet, let alone a false one. You could change the spelling to be more accurate, and call him a Profit.

  • Hard Little Machine

    nope. just another schizophrenic child raping voice hearing asshole.

    • dance…dancetotheradio

      Like Louis Riel.
      By the way, it was Traitor Day in Manitoba on Monday this week.

      • Justin St.Denis

        We seem to share a perspective on Riel, too. Are you sure we aren’t related? 😉

    • Justin St.Denis

      Now, having an asshole that can hear voices IS rather unique! 😉

  • If Islam is not the work of the devil, you can be sure he is smiling about it.

  • ontario john

    If Muhammad was around today, he would be in a mental hospital as a sociopath, in prison for molesting small children, or be Education Minister for Premier Wynne.

    • Etobicoke_Gladiator

      If M. was around today, he would outdo Hitler. That, in a nutshell, is my opinion of Islam.

    • If Mo was around today, he would be a Muslim and as such wold be EXEMPT from being “in a mental hospital as a sociopath, in prison for molesting small children.”

  • luna

    It’s a case of either/or. Either the New Testament account of Jesus is true or Muhammad’s account is true. Since they contradict each other, they both can’t be true.

    They can’t both be true, but that doesn’t mean either must be true.

    • Shebel

      What is Muhammad’s account?

  • Etobicoke_Gladiator

    Maimonides was once asked why, if Judaism was true, that there were so many more Christians and Muslims. Maimonides answered, quite simply, that to demonstrate God’s design for the world, he created two equally numerous religions far more numerous in membership than the tiny number of Jews by comparison. Judaism, Christianity, or Islam….. which is true? which is false?

    However, by my way of thinking, which religion allows rooms for others to exist and worship freely? Only Judaism and Christianity, respectively, allow for that and are therefore true. Islam is completely incompatible with allowing for the freedom of others. I could blab on and on about this and elaborate, but that’s my point for now. I would happily engage in conversation with any BCF readers about this, Jewish or Christian, if they wish.

    • Justin St.Denis

      Can’t disagree with your logic. It’s very….logical! 😉

  • Canadian

    Catholic leaders have sold out, that`s all.

    • Justin St.Denis

      Right up to and including Pope Evita.

      • Canadian

        It`s always been for power or money.

  • Miss Trixie

    [1] The Basilica of San Petronio is the main church of Bologna, Emilia Romagna, northern Italy. It dominates the Piazza Maggiore. It is the fifteenth largest church in the world, stretching for 132 meters in length and 60 meters in width, while the vault reaches 45 meters inside and 51 meters in the facade.

    The basilica is dedicated to the patron saint of the city, Saint Petronius, who was the bishop of Bologna in the fifth century.

    In 2002, five men who it was believed were connected to Al Qaeda and were planning to blow up the building, were arrested. Again in 2006, plans by Muslim terrorists to destroy the Basilica were thwarted by Italian police. The terrorists claimed that a 15th-century fresco inside was insulting to Islam. The fresco, painted by Giovanni da Modena, represents a scene from Dante Alighieri’s Inferno, and depicts Muhammad in Hell being devoured by demons.


    Such imagery has been part of Western and Islamic culture since the Middle Ages.

    • Justin St.Denis

      Muslims have, historically, behaved like demons, so it is hardly surprising that religious art over the past thousand years illustrates this truth about islam and muslims. Satanic and demonic – this is islam/muslims in a nutshell.

  • Shebel

    Strange–I have no problem respecting just about every religion in the World. I like to think that the Native Hunters and Gathers worshipped the same God as Me. Just different names , which is logical.

    I can’t help it— everything about Islam—-I associate with EVIL.

    • Justin St.Denis

      Maybe you are onto something there! Spread the word!

  • Barrington Minge

    As an atheist, I do not support any form of religion, but I do respect those who have beliefs…except for Islam. I can find nothing about that religion that I can respect.
    Strange that it is the only one….or is it?

    • Justin St.Denis

      No it is not the only one. The other evil “religion” goes by the name “Progressivism”.

  • Jabberwokk


    Jesus or Barabas…

    And if history repeats itself it’s gonna be Barabas once more.