UK: The majority of voters doubt that Islam is compatible with British values

The fact the internet is littered with graphics like this bothers me.

Cold War historian John Lewis Gaddis once divided his colleagues into “lumpers” and “splitters”. Those in the first camp usually sought to generalise about neat patterns that reduce the untidiness of history, he noted, while the second group preferred to reject these patterns in favour of complexity and endless distinctions. Getting the right balance between lumpers and splitters, wrote Gaddis, was “no easy thing”.

It seems a cultural version of the lumper-splitter problem now burdens the painful debate on why a steady flow of young Britons are aspiring to become jihadi brides and henchmen.

Theories from the Left have included cultural insensitivity, the provocation of Islamophobes, marginalisation by the state, victimisation by its security services, villainous Western foreign policy and neo-imperialism, or just Tony Blair.

Commentators on the Right have variously emphasised the failure of multiculturalism and immigration policy, the influence of unassimilated enclaves, unimpeded hate speech, inadequate funding for security services, embedded ideology within Islam itself, and the low self-esteem of loners.
In the process, pundits for each camp have lambasted the other, with Left accusing Right of conflating British Muslim identity with fundamentalism, and vice versa for refusing to acknowledge the cultural or religious dimensions of the issue…

Share
  • Academics are as bad as the chattering and governing classes, most among them lack common sense. Even if they possessed a sufficient quantity most again would be too fearful to speak the truth.

    I trust in the common man to tell the truth about Islam. They have the most to lose.

    • Yusuf_Al_Kafir

      The cowardly academics are only looking to save their precious jobs.

    • Frau Katze

      They have ZERO common sense.

    • J. C.

      All college, no knowledge…

  • Dana Garcia

    The graphic left out the sixth pillar of Islam — mass murder.

    • dance…dancetotheradio

      Aanndd Satan!

  • Hard Little Machine

    Islam does not care. It will be imposed at gunpoint.

  • dance…dancetotheradio

    Christians submit to the laws of God.
    It’s called science.